Decadently delicious, this Keto Peanut Butter Pie is nestled under a thick layer of chocolate and whipped cream. A winning trio every time!
Keto Peanut Butter Pie
Long live peanut butter and chocolate, the reigning superstar culinary duo! I know the celebration of these two ingredients is made ad nauseam, but it cannot be avoided.
Sometimes I wish I could just send these treats right through the blog to you, so you could enjoy them without any of the work! But there is something beautiful when you create a pie in your own kitchen and the satisfaction that comes with it.
Pie Options
We have three keto crusts that will work beautifully with this recipe, the chocolate is included below, but feel free to use the graham crust from our Keto Pumpkin Square recipe or our traditional buttery crust from our Low-Carb Lemon Meringue Pie recipe. This pie can also be made dairy-free by using coconut milk and subbing in coconut whipped cream for topping, see recipe below for instructions.
Whipped Topping (see below for dairy-free option):
1 pint heavy whipping cream
2 tablespoons Swerve Confectioner Sweetener
1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
Coconut Whipped Topping Option (A dollop on each slice)
The solid cream from two cans of chilled coconut milk (view instructions for details)
1/4 teaspoon gelatin
1/8 teaspoon vanilla extract
tiny pinch of Stevia or Swerve
Instructions
Preheat oven to 350 degrees
Start with your crust. In a large bowl, whisk together almond flour, Swerve, coconut flour, cocoa powder and salt. With a pastry cutter, cut your chilled butter into the flour blend. Make sure butter pieces are no larger than pea-size.
Add milk and vanilla into flour/butter mixture and slowly work into dough. (I prefer to use my hands, but a food processor works as well). Dough will be sticky. Shape dough into ball. (Dough will be pliable and have a similar texture to soft play-doh). Use your dough immediately.
Press and flatten your dough into a 9 inch pie pan and work dough up the sides and around the edges. You may find it easier to work with the dough if you dip your fingers into water first. I keep a small cup by my working station.
Prick your pie dough with a fork and place onto a cookie sheet. Bake at 350 degrees for 18-20 minutes and allow crust to cool completely before adding filling. The crust will firm up during the cooling process. (You can cool pie crust in the freezer if you’re in a hurry).
FILLING:
While your crust is cooling, let’s create your filling. In a large, dry bowl add Swerve, gelatin and salt. Whisk dry ingredients together. Then while whisking, slowly add in your milk, vanilla and egg yolks. Whisk until evenly combined.
In a separate bowl, place your cup of peanut butter, we’ll add that in later.
Pour milk mixture into medium sized pot and cook on medium heat until you reach a boil. (Make sure you are stirring at frequent intervals). Allow contents to lightly boil about 15 seconds while whisking then turn off your burner. Now add in your peanut butter and whisk until it’s nice and smooth, incorporated evenly into the liquid. Now add your 1 tbsp of butter, and stir again until smooth.
Pour your filling into your prepared, cooled pie crust and allow to cool on the countertop for 15 minutes. Then carefully place in the refrigerator overnight to set. For quick setup, place pie in freezer for 3 hours–works like a charm, especially when you need it fast! (After your pie is thoroughly chilled, I recommend leaving it out for about ten minutes before adding the cream topping and serving so it can return to it’s super silky texture.
Chocolate Topping:Â Melt your 4 oz of unsweetened chocolate in a microwave safe dish at 30-45 second intervals, stirring each time. When it is thoroughly melted, add your coconut oil and stir until smooth. Sift the 1/3 cup of Swerve in and stir quickly with a dry fork or whisk until nice and smooth.
Pour melted chocolate over the cooled peanut butter filling, making sure to reach the edges. Place the pie in the freezer for 10 minutes for the chocolate to set.
WHIPPED TOPPING:
In a large bowl blend your heavy whipping cream with a hand mixer on high for a few minutes until cream thickens and you have soft peaks–then sift in your Swerve and vanilla extract. Whip another minute or so until firm. Spread or pipe over chilled pie and top with shaved, unsweetened chocolate if desired. Serve and enjoy!!
For Coconut Whipped Topping: Blend together your coconut whipped topping right before serving the pie. Open two cans of chilled coconut milk and remove just the cream on top, being careful not to transfer liquid a long with it. Place the cream in your chilled mixing bowl. Sprinkle 1/4 tsp of gelatin overtop and add a tiny pinch of sweetener and 1/8th tsp of vanilla extract. Blend for just 10-15 seconds, over blending tends to loosen the cream. Place in piping bag with star tip or spoon a dollop on each pie serving. Serve and enjoy! Cover and refrigerate leftovers.
*This post may contain affiliate links, I receive a small commission if you make a purchase using these links. Income allows us to purchase products to test the recipes you see here!
Such a gorgeous yummy pie Catherine!! This is definitely going on the January baking list. You always make the most delicious pie recipes!
★★★★★
Aww thank you my friend!! Can’t wait for you to try it!
Chocolate and peanut butter are the best! This pie is certainly the perfect way to enjoy the two. I can’t wait to treat my family to this dessert!
Thank you so much Noelle!! I really hope you guys love it! 😀
This is so my kind of dessert, Catherine! Oh chocolate and peanut butter goes delightfully well together! I would not be able to stop eating this!
★★★★★
Aww haha thank you Katherine!! It’s so hard to put the fork down with this one! 😉